I heard this version and… it changed my view on Jazz as a whole. Yes, it’s THAT good!
People who know me know that I MUCH prefer the Blues over Jazz. Apparently that’s because SO MANY JAZZ SINGERS REALLY REALLY SUCK!!!! Big time!

Hugh Laurie sings this (and plays the piano), and now I’m a Jazz believer again. True.
Great actor? Sure. But when “House” is done, he needs to continue with his musical career. I ain’t askin’! I’m sayin’.

Compare Hugh’s version to Lou’s version, and see the difference. Make your own decision. Lou’s version was with the trumpet (obviously)… Hugh’s vocal oriented (with a piano minor, granted) is… a much better version. 

Does your view differ?  Leave your opinion and let me know.

Enjoy!

(This is now my preferred version of “St. James Infirmary”)
And yes… after years and years… someone has bested Lou. /sigh